Potbelly Menu Guide: Prices, Categories & What to Order
Potbelly Sandwich Shop has grown from a single Chicago storefront into a national chain, but the menu has stayed fairly consistent in structure: toasted sandwiches, salads, soups, sides, and a dessert lineup built around milkshakes and cookies. If you're trying to get a full picture of what's available before you order — or you're comparing categories to plan a group order — this guide walks through each part of the menu and where to find more detail.
This page is maintained independently as a menu-information resource and is not affiliated with or operated by Potbelly Sandwich Shop. Menu items, prices, and availability can vary by location, so treat the information here as a starting point rather than a guarantee of what you'll see at checkout.
What Is on the Potbelly Menu?
The Potbelly menu is organized around five main categories: sandwiches, salads, soups and mac & cheese, chips and sides, and shakes and desserts. Sandwiches are the anchor of the menu and come in original and skinny sizes, while the other categories function mainly as sides, lighter alternatives, or add-ons to round out a meal. Most items are customizable, and pricing depends on size, toppings, and location.
A Quick Tour of Each Menu Category
Sandwiches
The sandwiches menu is the core of Potbelly's identity — toasted subs built around classic combinations like Italian, turkey breast, ham, and meatball, along with a loaded specialty option and a veggie build for those skipping meat. Sandwiches come in original and skinny sizes, and most toppings can be customized at no extra charge. For a full breakdown of options, sizes, and pricing factors, see the Potbelly sandwiches menu guide.
Salads
For a lighter option or a lower-carb alternative to a sandwich, the salads menu typically includes a handful of house salads built around similar proteins to the sandwich lineup — chicken, turkey, or Italian meats over greens, along with dressing choices. Salads are a common pick for anyone managing calories without giving up protein. Details on specific salads and how they compare to sandwich options are covered in the Potbelly salads menu guide.
Soups and Mac & Cheese
The soups and mac & cheese menu rotates more than any other category, with a small number of daily or weekly soup options alongside a baked mac & cheese that's often ordered as a side or a light meal on its own. Soups are a popular pairing with a half sandwich for a more balanced, lower-cost lunch. The current rotation and typical soup offerings are broken down in the Potbelly soups and mac & cheese menu guide.
Chips and Sides
Chips and sides round out most orders, ranging from standard bagged chips to heartier sides depending on the location. This category is usually the easiest place to adjust a meal up or down in calories, since sides can be swapped for something lighter (or skipped) without changing the main order. A full comparison of side options is available in the Potbelly chips and sides menu guide.
Shakes and Desserts
Desserts are anchored by hand-mixed milkshakes in a range of flavors, along with cookies and other baked goods. This is the most indulgent part of the menu and is generally treated as an add-on rather than part of the core meal. Flavor options and typical pricing are covered in the Potbelly shakes and desserts menu guide.
Potbelly Menu Prices
Prices across every category vary by location, region, and ordering method. In-store pricing is typically lower than ordering through third-party delivery apps, which usually add service fees or markups on top of the menu price. Because of this, it's more useful to think of pricing in ranges by category rather than fixed numbers:
- Sandwiches tend to be the most expensive single item, with skinny sizes priced lower than originals
- Salads are generally priced similarly to sandwiches, sometimes slightly less
- Soups and mac & cheese are usually priced as sides or smaller add-ons, though full-size portions cost more
- Chips and sides are the lowest-cost add-ons on the menu
- Shakes and desserts vary the most by flavor and size, with shakes typically costing more than cookies
For exact current pricing, checking your local Potbelly's in-store menu or ordering app is the most reliable approach.
Best Menu Picks for Different Needs
- Quick solo lunch: A skinny sandwich or a salad, ordered on its own
- Lighter meal: A salad or a half sandwich paired with a cup of soup
- Bigger appetite: An original-size specialty sandwich paired with chips or mac & cheese
- Group or catering order: A mix of sandwiches and salads, with sides ordered separately to fit different preferences
- Treat or add-on: A shake or cookie added to any of the above
How to Navigate the Menu When Ordering
A simple approach that works for most orders:
- Start with the main item — sandwich or salad, based on appetite and dietary preference
- Add a side deliberately — soup, mac & cheese, or chips, chosen based on whether you want something light or filling
- Decide on dessert separately — treat shakes and cookies as optional add-ons rather than defaults
- Check pricing before finalizing — especially if ordering through a delivery app, where totals can run noticeably higher than in-store
- Confirm availability locally — seasonal items and rotating soups vary by location and time of year
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main categories on the Potbelly menu? The menu is organized into sandwiches, salads, soups and mac & cheese, chips and sides, and shakes and desserts, with sandwiches serving as the core of most orders.
Are Potbelly menu prices the same everywhere? No. Prices vary by location, region, and ordering method, with delivery apps typically costing more than ordering in-store.
What's a good lighter option on the menu? A salad or a skinny sandwich, optionally paired with a cup of soup instead of chips, is generally the lighter route through the menu.
Does the menu change by season? Some items, particularly soups and limited-time sandwiches, rotate seasonally or vary by location, while the core sandwich and salad lineup stays fairly consistent.
Is this website affiliated with Potbelly Sandwich Shop? No. This site is an independent menu-information resource and is not operated by or affiliated with Potbelly Sandwich Shop.
Where can I find prices and details for a specific category? Each menu category has its own dedicated guide — sandwiches, salads, soups and mac & cheese, chips and sides, and shakes and desserts — linked throughout this page.
Final Takeaway
The Potbelly menu is built around a simple structure: a main item (sandwich or salad), an optional side (soup, mac & cheese, or chips), and an optional dessert (shake or cookie). Prices and availability shift by location, so it's worth confirming details locally before ordering. For a deeper look at any single category, the guides linked above break down items, pricing factors, and best picks in more detail.
Comments
Post a Comment